Book Review: The Sweet Pea Book

– Posted in: Book reviews, Plant info

I am a sweet pea ignoramus. I tried growing them once, after reading an article in an early Fine Gardening issue. I thought they’d be just perfect climbing up the chicken wire fence surrounding the chicken yard, and after learning how fragrant they were, well, I couldn’t wait. They did rather poorly, and though I’m sure I chose a variety guaranteed to be fragrant, there wasn’t enough of a fragrance to make a lasting impression. Sigh.

Consequently I eagerly pulled The Sweet Pea Book by Graham Rice off my public library’s “New” shelf when I spied it there a week or two ago. Timber Press books are known for going into the kind of depth that passionate gardeners crave, and I’ve enjoyed every book by Graham Rice that I’ve ever read, so it was a no-brainer.

Unfortunately, this book wasn’t written for as ignorant an ignoramus as I am when it comes to sweet peas. Don’t get me wrong; there’s plenty of useful information and it’s written well. It’s just that, well, it’s in the wrong order. The very first chapter is on the history of sweet pea breeding. If you’re really into sweet peas, you need to know this stuff, but if you’ve never grown sweet peas before, or if, like me, you’ve tried and failed, what you want to know most of all is how to grow them. That doesn’t come till chapter nine.

But you know, I’m enough of a flower geek to find all that breeding stuff interesting, especially the idea that breeders back then weren’t always too worried about making sure their seed came true before putting it on the market. Or that, “in the early years of [the twentieth] century, new Spencer varieties in the same colour as previous Grandifloras were often simply given a modified version of the Grandiflora name, e.g. ‘Flora Norton Spencer’ is the same colour as ‘Flora Norton’ but in the waved Spencer form.” (p. 38). My biggest problem was the terms he threw around: standard, keel, wings. Now, I know I have seen a diagram somewhere, sometime in the past, where these terms were illustrated, but as I was reading the book I couldn’t dredge it up from memory. But I thought to myself, “Surely there’s a illustration somewhere in the book labeling the structure of a sweet pea flower.” But, no. I’m sure the editor and author thought everyone knows what is the keel and what is the standard, but you see, I am a sweet pea ignoramus. Sigh.

Correction: I was a sweet-pea ignoramus. I now know I was doing just about everything wrong. The soil was not free draining enough or fertile enough, both of which I suspected, but it also wasn’t deep enough. That surprised me. In their native haunts, sweet peas germinate in the fall, sending down deep roots but growing slowly above. Then in the spring they grow quickly upward and get all their blooming done before the heat of summer. If you want them to do well, they’ve just got to get their roots down. So, there are sweet peas in my future. The area along the chicken fence has been rather neglected of late, but if I relocate the daffodils blooming there, and prepare the soil properly, I just might try sweet peas next spring. Actually, no “might” about it; the big “if” concerns the relocating and preparing, which I might not get around to. If I do find the time to do all that digging, I will definitely be planting sweet peas.

The very last chapter is about growing sweet peas in the United States:

It is a common misconception that sweet peas are impossible to grow in the United States. This, I have to confess, is often claimed by the British who like to think that they’re the best at everything horticultural. . . . Yet wild sweet peas are native to Sicily whose Mediterranean climate is matched more closely in some parts of the United States than in the relatively uniform cool British conditions

Mr. Rice then offers advice, based on climate more than geography, for various areas of the United States, covering what varieties to plant and when to plant them, and other tricks of the trade as appropriate. If you’ve been having trouble growing sweet peas, this chapter could be worth the price of the book for you.

The one thing Mr. Rice never discusses, and which I’ve always wondered about, is the use of legume inoculant. It’s suggested as being beneficial for growing garden peas (that is, the ones you eat as vegetables) and I wonder if it would help sweet peas as well.

Oh, and I might as well confess, the book answered one more question for me, a question that has nothing to do with sweet peas. I always wondered why Graham Rice decided to take up a second residence in Pennsylvania. What was lacking in Great Britain that the United States supplied? The answer, dear readers, is on the back cover.

About the Author

Kathy Purdy is a colchicum evangelist, converting unsuspecting gardeners into colchicophiles. She would be delighted to speak to your group about colchicums or other gardening topics. Kathy’s been writing since 4th grade, gardening since high school, and blogging since 2002.

When dealing with frost it is always best to be paranoid. In the spring never think it is too late for one more frost to come. And in the fall never think it too early.

~Rundy in Frost

Comments on this entry are closed.

Craig Levy April 14, 2007, 8:21 am

If your current garden pea techniques are working, apply them to your Sweets for equal successful. An inoculent is useful but nicking the seeds with a sharp knife or razor blade will also work.

Deep soils enriched with compost and manure are a pleasure to work with. I’m ambivalent about an absolute need for deep soils. One assignment I had was growing Sweets in gallon pots on stakes. The plants were bushy and free-flowering but murderous to keep upright and well-watered.

Most garden books, especially ones devoted to a particular group of plants, begin with a chapter on origin and history. I find the information only mildly interesting and would prefer it being the final chapter in every book.

It is odd to not have illustrations diagramming the flowers and foliage. Sweets and other peas have such interesting and unique flowers, foliage, and stems it’s a pity the author missed the opportunity to show them off.

rosemarie hanson April 7, 2007, 1:09 pm

One of my favorite sweet pea websites is Fragrant Garden Nursery, located in Oregon. They have a lot of helpful cultural information.

LostRoses April 7, 2007, 12:36 pm

My dear departed mother-in-law could throw sweet pea seeds in the ground anywhere and they grew beautifully. I never could get them to grow, despite my desire to have those lovely blooms and tendrils. She said her secret was that she planted them on St. Patrick’s Day. That didn’t work for me either!

Barbara in Finger Lakes April 6, 2007, 2:38 pm

My mother (a superb gardener) struggled to grow sweet peas in New England for decades. When I moved to Iowa, I rented a garden plot, and what the heck, threw some sweet peas in with the corn and the broccoli. They were glorious. Just the deep sweet black Iowa dirt, and lots of sunlight, and they bloomed like fools and smelled as good as a damask rose. However, since returning to the northeast, I have been totally unable to grow them. They put up a little feeble growth and go nowhere. I am thinking of asking a friend in Iowa to mail me some of her dirt!

Annie in Austin April 6, 2007, 9:24 am

Kathy, although my sweetpea ventures have been far from successful, the one thing I did know about was the traditional method of deep planting. But I didn’t hear about it in a gardening book – I learned about it decades ago, while reading an Agatha Christie mystery. Lucy Eyelesbarrow helps out Miss Marple, and proves her worth by “trenching for sweet peas in the proper way”, a phrase that sent me looking for further details. Gardening trivia shows up all over, doesn’t it?

Good luck with growing them!

Annie at the Transplantable Rose