Campanula rapunculoides: Good looking but hardly innocent
A while back I wrote an essay for Horticulture detailing my attempt to figure out the difference between ladybells and creeping bellflower, and I wrote up a
blog post with additional information. Anne Larson, the Des Moines Gardening Examiner, has tracked down more information about these two plants, including
how to determine if you really have ladybells. One expert she quoted said he has yet to find a bona fide Adenophora in the horticultural trade. You might want to read the article and check out your ladybells next summer.
Tagged as:
adenophora,
bellflower,
campanula,
invasive_plants,
ladybells,
thugs
Kathy Purdy discovered the joys of writing in fourth grade, when she started corresponding with a former classmate. She's been writing letters ever since, first on looseleaf, then electronically, and now as weblog entries. That makes you, the blog reader, her pen pal. Her first independent (though frustrating) attempts at gardening were made in high school, though the gardening bug didn't bite hard until her mid-thirties, when she found herself mistress of a rural home on 15 acres. •
USDA Hardiness Zone:4 • AHS Heat Zone: 3 • Location: rural;
Southern Tier of NY • Geographic type: foothills of Appalachian
Mountains • Soil Type: acid clay • Experience level:
intermediate
• Particular interests: colchicums, narcissus, cottage gardening, NY
native plants, gardening with/for children
When you're hanging on by a thread, identify that thread and do all you can to strengthen it. Gardening is my thread, consistently providing therapy through years of ups and downs. If this blink in time seems a bit crazier, well, perhaps it is. Gardening serves as a gentle reminder that the wheel turns and seasons come and go, each filled with its own impossibly tender beauty.
an eclectic garden
{ 9 comments… read them below or add one }
Doesn’t ANYONE know how to get rid of the companula rapunculoides? Mine loves to grow into the roots of other plants and hide in their foliage. We have totally dug up beds to try and clean it out but it always comes back worse than before. SOMETHING must kill it.
Twitter: @artbysherylhotmail.com
I can’t help it, I love any kind of canpanula. There are so many of them and they are all such great garden plants. Perhaps if it is cut back and not allowed to go to seed, it will behave itself.
I have had some horribly agressive, invasive plants over the years. I don’t find this one that bad.
Ah yes…I can’t decide if I hate this plant…I tend to just round it up because of the way it spreads into my lawn. Nice blog!
Twitter: @truegrit
I wrote up a profile of Adenophora confusa, which is the way it was identified when I ordered it from WFF. I have good clay loam soil and it has never been aggressive for me. I’m not familiar with the evil twin…
.-= Ilona´s last blog ..Contorted Hazel =-.
Oh yes. I know this plant (the bad one) well. I don’t really have the space to worry about it, but it runs rampant through our alley. I pick it now and then.
Interesting – I thought I had both in my garden. The Adenophera I bought from White Flower Farm 12 years ago or so. It has never been aggressive in the least, either by seed or rhizome. In fact I’ve often wished it had a bit more oomph. The campanula came on a pass along plant. I weed it often and never let it go to seed so far it been supressed. I take care of several gardens where it was given free reign before my arrival – so I do know what a nightmare it can be. Everything is dormant now, but I’ll do some careful checking next fall. If my Adenophera is really a Campanula – I wonder what species – it certainly is not very rapacious.
Twitter: @suburbangarden
I just always assumed that Adenophora was a nasty thug. I’m always afraid of anything with the epithet, rapunculoides, which shares a root with rapacious, meaning greedy or ravenous.
.-= Mr. McGregor’s Daughter´s last blog ..Garden Wish List =-.
Twitter: @GardenJunkie1
Oh no. I just posted a picture of my Adenophora for Garden Bloggers Bloom Day. At least, that’s what I thought it was and what it was called when I bought it through mail order from High Country Gardens two years ago. It’s been quite well-behaved so I thought it was the “real thing” (in contrast to those dratted Cherry Bells in the front garden which took over most of the bed within 6 months!). But now I find out that it’s probably “campanula horribilis” as someone called it. After reading Anne Larson’s article I peeled a couple of flowers only to find a disk. Argh. So now what do I do – pull out a plant I adore (and that, so far, hasn’t spread much) or let it go and realize that I may be fighting it for years to come?!
.-= Garden Junkie´s last blog ..Garden Bloggers Bloom Day – November 2009 =-.
Twitter: @flowergardengal
Kathy, I enjoy mysteries like this. I also enjoy stories about good plant intentions that good bad—like Kudzu that ate the South. Kudzu was suppose to help erosion and now we have it forming sculptures of green monsters as it covers trees, houses, power lines—
.-= Anna/Flowergardengirl´s last blog ..For 15 minutes, I’ve been listening to someone =-.